Allan Martinson, managing partner of Estonian private equity company MTVP, saw Baltic companies he invested in cut spending as much as 30 percent starting in 2008 to cope with Europe’s worst recession.
They all survived, even as their earnings plunged in part because of government austerity measures. Now that Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania are growing, Martinson is putting money into such startups as Estonian online dating site Flirtic.
The Baltics’ ability to tolerate economic pain has been praised in recent months by German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Klaus Regling, chief of the European Financial Stability Facility. Latvia’s gross domestic product fell 18 percent in 2009 and Estonia’s fell 14 percent. That’s what it will take to get Greece, Portugal, Ireland and Spain through their current crisis, Martinson says.
“I would be very surprised if the southern European countries would be able to go through with necessary measures on their own,” Martinson, 44, said in a phone interview in Tallinn. “I think it will take very strong coercion to get them to do that. Perhaps Europe needs financial police.”
He has been investing in the Baltic region since the countries emerged from the collapse of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s, when a computer cost seven times his monthly wage.
After suffering through the worst drop in economic output in the world, the Baltic countries have been growing on a quarterly basis since the beginning of 2010. Estonian stocks were the world’s third-best performers last year.
Rising Ratings
Latvia’s credit rating was raised to the lowest investment grade from junk status by Fitch Ratings yesterday; the country also has investment-grade ratings from Moody’s Investor’s Service. Standard & Poor’s rates Latvia BB+, its highest speculative grade, with a positive outlook.
Credit default swaps, which investors use to protect against default or speculate on creditworthiness, in the three countries are below those for Greece, Ireland, and Portugal. Greece is only slightly less risky than Pakistan while Estonia is ranked almost as safe as France, according to CDS prices.
Lithuania’s Apranga AB, the biggest Baltic clothing retailer, returned to profit last year and now plans to open as many as eight new shops this year. The company had cut its workforce by 16 percent in 2009 and trimmed wages by 30 percent to cope with tumbling consumer spending. Shares rose 160 percent last year.
Estonia, which adopted the euro in January, saw its OMX Tallinn Index rise 72.6 percent last year. Latvia and Lithuania were among the top 10 performers. Greek stocks fell 41 percent.
Political Favor
What’s more, political leaders in the three countries have found support from the electorate. Estonian Prime Minister Andrus Ansip widened his government coalition’s majority in elections held on March 6. Latvians in October re-elected Prime Minister Valdis Dombrovskis, while Lithuanian Premier Andrius Kubilius’s governing party garnered twice as many votes as polls predicted in municipal elections on Feb. 27.
Estonia mastered the economic crisis “in an admirable way,” Merkel said in a Berlin news conference with Ansip on Oct. 21. “It’s a good, even remarkable signal that Estonia fully met the criteria for joining the euro during such difficult economic times.”
Greece, which turned to a group led by the EU and the IMF for a 110-billion euro ($152 billion) bailout in May last year, had its credit rating cut three steps to Ba1 by Moody’s Investors Service on March 7.
Street Protests
Greeks took to the streets with 496 protests and marches last year, according to police, as the government passed tax increases and budget cuts to meet the terms of its loan. Three people were killed in a fire during riots in Athens in May.
And Moody’s cut Spain’s rating to Aa2 on March 10, saying the cost of shoring up the banking industry will eclipse government estimates.
Ireland’s austerity program, bank bailout and international loan led to an election win for the opposition last month, the biggest political shift in the country’s history short term personal loan. The previous government lost support by turning to the IMF and euro countries for an 85-billion euro rescue package in November.
To be sure, it wasn’t all stoicism in the Baltics. A peaceful protest of about 10,000 people on Jan. 13, 2009, turned violent as a few hundred people rioted in the old city of Riga. The Latvian government collapsed about a month later.
Then Lithuanians rioted, about a month after Kubilius took power in general elections and after the government announced tax increases and spending cuts.
Euro Discipline
In both regions, currency devaluation, the traditional path to exports and growth, is not an option. The southern European countries are in the euro, as is Estonia, and Latvia and Lithuania aim to join by 2014 and thus have to limit exchange fluctuation.
A key difference, though, may lie in the recent history of the Baltics, said Hardo Pajula, an economist with SEB AB in Tallinn. Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia, occupied by the Soviet Union for almost 50 years, lived through its collapse. The last few years before independence in 1991 brought hyperinflation, food and fuel shortages and a wipeout of savings.
“It is rather hard to envisage a pampered citizen of a mature Western welfare state accepting the pay cuts that were pushed through in this part of the woods in the last couple of years,” Pajula said. “A great fuss has been made about the Baltic GDPs having fallen by 16 percent or 17 percent in 2009, but you have to see these things in context. Aggregate output fell perhaps by 70 percent at the beginning of the 1990s.”
Food Coupons
Shortages were so severe that coupons for staples like food and soap and alcohol had to be used. Inflation reached about 1,000 percent in the region in 1992 and savings were wiped out.
EU membership in 2004 led to a fall in interest rates, a boom in lending and rising housing prices and wages. Then the global credit crisis hit just as the regional expansion was running out of steam.
Latvia has implemented austerity measures equal to about 16 percent of GDP since the end of 2008, when it turned to a group led by the EU and the International Monetary Fund for a 7.5 billion-euro loan. Estonia passed measures equal to 9 percent of GDP; Lithuania’s budget discipline totaled 12 percent of GDP in a plan the IMF called “unprecedented by historical and international standards.”
Over Years
While the Greek package agreed to last year calls for budget cuts worth 14 percent of GDP, it will take place over four years. Spain is enacting austerity worth 8.2 percent of GDP between 2009 and 2013.
To be sure, the deal struck by euro-area leaders last weekend to create a permanent safety net for indebted countries starting in 2013 and lower interest costs for Greece boosted the chances they will survive the debt crisis.
Only Greece and Ireland have had to seek aid; Portugal says no bailout is needed and Spain is moving ahead to rescue its banks without emergency aid. The country’s Ibex 35 Index is up 6.2 percent and Greece’s ASE Index up 18 percent this year, while the Stoxx Europe 600 Index is down 0.8 percent.
Greece’s public debt, though, was 140 percent of GDP and its budget deficit 9.6 percent last year, the European Commission said.
Estonia’s measures helped keep its public debt at the EU’s lowest level, 8 percent of GDP. The budget deficit declined to 1 percent of GDP. Exports of goods rose 35 percent last year to a record after declining 23 percent in 2009.
To Martinson, the same future could await Europe’s heavily indebted countries if they take the needed measures.
“With or without a European financial police, southern Europe will have to go through with own austerity program anyway,” he said. “It is just a matter of time.”
Source